Former Bachelorette star Katie Thurston made headlines after publicly calling out her former costar Cody Menk for an inappropriate remark about her recent wedding photos shared on social media. Thurston, who married comedian Jeff Arcuri in a private ceremony, posted pictures from their special day only to have Menk, a contestant from her season, comment, “Good couple! Both solid 5s.” This remark was widely perceived as dismissive and rude, prompting Katie to clap back via her Instagram Stories. She reposted a screenshot of Menk’s comment, adding, “Remember this guy from my season? Me neither. But he’s still here lurking on my page,” and sarcastically thanked him for being a fan.

The incident quickly gained traction among Bachelor Nation fans, many of whom rallied behind Thurston with messages of support. Some fans even responded to her original wedding post, asking about Cody’s whereabouts, to which Thurston humorously replied that she had already blocked him, ensuring he would never be able to comment again. The exchange drew attention not only for its shade but also as yet another example of Katie’s adeptness at handling trolls and negativity online. Her ability to keep things lighthearted, even in the face of thoughtless criticism, resonated with her followers and underlined her reputation for authenticity and humor.

Cody Menk’s history on the show adds context to his latest comment. He was eliminated early in Katie’s Bachelorette season after she confronted him about concerns raised by another contestant who knew him outside the show and described him as unkind. Menk’s stint ended in week 2, leaving little lasting impact, and his social media presence is now kept private. Meanwhile, Katie, who became a fan favorite both on Matt James’ Bachelor season and during her own run as Bachelorette, has had her personal life and health journey widely supported by fans, especially following her Stage IV breast cancer diagnosis earlier this year.

Through it all, Katie has remained open about her challenges and joys, sharing updates on her treatment, mental health, and married life with Arcuri. Her response to Cody’s derogatory comment is indicative of her commitment to staying positive and rising above negativity. She has discussed how laughter and connection with Jeff have sustained her, even as she undergoes rigorous medical treatment. In interviews, Thurston has expressed gratitude for the support from both her husband and Bachelor Nation, emphasizing the importance of kindness and empathy, especially during difficult times.