Madharaasi Ghaati Review Clash
By Asmita - Sep 05, 2025
Tamil cinema sees a box office clash between "Madharaasi" starring Sivakarthikeyan and "Ghaati" featuring Anushka Shetty. "Madharaasi" impresses with Sivakarthikeyan's acting and action sequences, but criticism arises for the music and pacing. In contrast, "Ghaati" struggles with cliched storytelling and underdeveloped characters despite Anushka Shetty's strong performance. The clash generates buzz, dividing audience preferences and impacting box office collections. Audience reactions reflect critics' mixed feelings towards both films.

Review image via picpedia.org
On September 5, 2025, ,[object Object], witnessed a significant ,[object Object], with the simultaneous release of two highly anticipated films, "Madharaasi" starring Sivakarthikeyan and ",[object Object]," featuring Anushka Shetty. Directed by A. R. Murugadoss, "Madharaasi" marks Sivakarthikeyan’s first release of the year and introduces audiences to a gripping action thriller. The story revolves around Raghu, an ordinary man involuntarily involved in a dangerous gun-smuggling network along the Tamil Nadu border. The film features intense action sequences and psychological undertones, notably a possible split personality disorder adding depth to the narrative. Reviews acknowledge Sivakarthikeyan’s commendable performance and thrilling action scenes, though some critics feel the second half drags and the music falls short of expectations.
In contrast, ",Ghaati,," directed by Krish Jagarlamudi, brings Anushka Shetty back to the Telugu screen with a crime drama set in the Western Ghats. Anushka plays Sheelavathi, whose serene life is disrupted by a conflict involving a new liquid-based cannabis business controlled by rival factions. Alongside Vikram Prabhu, who marks his Telugu debut, the film attempts to weave a tale of resistance and transformation. However, despite the compelling premise and Anushka’s presence, reviews suggest the execution falters with routine storytelling, weak villain characterization, and underwhelming emotional depth. Critics point out that Anushka’s powerful potential was underutilized, and the film lacks the intensity that audiences might expect from such a setting.
The ,box office clash, between these two films has generated considerable buzz. "Madharaasi," with the backing of A. R. Murugadoss and Sivakarthikeyan’s rising stardom, attracted fans eager for a high-octane thriller. Meanwhile, ",Ghaati," capitalizes on Anushka’s strong fan base and her commanding screen presence to draw family audiences. Industry experts noted the challenge this posed, as the divided audience might impact collections for both. Additionally, other films like "Little Hearts" and "Mirai" were also in contention on the same day, creating a competitive multiplex environment for viewers.
Audience reactions mirror the critics' mixed sentiments. "Madharaasi" viewers appreciated the film’s setup and Sivakarthikeyan’s portrayal but were divided on the screenplay's pacing, especially in the second half. Some found the movie predictable and overly dramatic, diluting the overall impact. On the other hand, ",Ghaati," received praise for its attempt at a fresh backdrop and Anushka’s performance, though many felt the film was weighed down by outdated direction and insufficient character development. The film’s loud background score and inserted songs were criticized for disrupting the narrative flow, further cooling the audience's enthusiasm.